Former Game of the Month
Editor's ChoiceFormer Game of the MonthEditor's Choice
| Title | Publisher | Score 1-100 | Date |
| Battle Beast | 7th Level | 88 | 1/96 |
| Big Red Racing | Domark | 73 | 7/96 |
| Brain Dead 13 | Readysoft | 81 | 4/96 |
| Commodore 64 Pack | Activision | 86 | 4/96 |
| DeathKeep | SSI | 75 | 7/96 |
| Descent : Levels | Interplay | 91 | 3/96 |
| Descent 2 | Interplay | 89 | 5/96 |
| Hi-Octane | Bullfrog | 86 | 2/96 |
| Magic Carpet 2 | Electronic Arts | 82 | 3/96 |
| Road Warrior | GameTek | 73 | 4/96 |
| Starball | GameTek | 70 | 5/96 |
| Super Stardust 96 | GameTek | 90 | 7/96 |
| Tracer | Interplay | 85 | 8/96 |
| The Web! | Empire Interactive | 88 | 7/96 |
| Wetlands | GameTek | 88 | 1/96 |
| Whiplash | Interplay | 85 | 4/96 |
| Wing Commander 4 | Origin | 79 | 5/96 |